voiceofsandiego.org: Cafesandiego... The Most Pressing Coastal Priority
an independent nonprofit |
We depend on your donations. Support us today.

The Most Pressing Coastal Priority

Published: Sunday, September 16, 2007 5:32 PM PDT



As an avid kayaker, I have had the pleasure of enjoying and becoming acquainted with California and Baja California's beautiful and unique coastline.

In my opinion, there is no doubt that many of the surrounding coastal communities' residents and officials -- including those in Mexico -- take our coastline for granted.

On a recent kayak trip, I traveled south from Imperial Beach to Rosarito, and on my way south I passed the well-known community of San Antonio del Mar, which is located about five miles south of the border.

As I kayaked into the vicinity of San Antonio del Mar, I came across what I consider the most severe example of environmental degradation I have ever witnessed. I was astounded to see a large area of brown water with an unusually large presence of marine birds and dolphins obviously feeding on something. I soon realized that I was paddling through a brown mixture of slimy untreated sewage. After kayaking for a few more minutes, I was further shocked by the concentration of the sewage and the vast span of coastline it covered. I was also surprised that there was not a containment crew trying to clean up the sewage.

When I returned to the site three days later, I was greatly disturbed to see that nothing had changed. All the while, I saw bathers swimming in the water, surfers surfing nearby and, of most concern, fishermen pulling fish out of the surrounding waters. There were no warning signs to inform the beachgoers or fishermen of what was obviously a public health hazard.

I have known for years that Tijuana has been unable to successfully process its sewage for decades and that the result has been frequent discharges into the Tijuana River Valley. Never did I imagine, however, that the problem occurred daily and the outflow drained directly into waters that were regularly frequented by the general public.

In fact, the condominium development proposed by Donald Trump is no more that a stone’s throw away from this outfall and will probably be sold touting the beautiful adjacent beaches. People will not know that by living there, they will be discharging their own sewage onto their beachfront property.

As I kayaked, I fought a very strong northerly current that is one of the strongest I have ever experienced in my years of kayaking along the coast. This uniquely strong current brings millions of gallons of this sewage into Playas de Tijuana, Imperial Beach, Silverstrand State Beach, and Coronado, which are frequented by millions of visitors and residents annually.

Sewage plume, San Antonio del Mar
The sewage plume can clearly be seen flowing north in an aerial view on Google Earth maps.

With the recent election of Tijuana’s new mayor, Jorge Ramos, and Baja California’s new governor, José Guadalupe Osuna Millán, an opportunity now exists to unite both San Diego and Mexico’s elected officials. Priority needs to be placed on preventing this type of sewage from entering our coastal waters. The hundreds of millions we propose to invest in improving water quality in San Diego by improving our creeks and watersheds and reducing discharge in our bays and beaches is but a mere drop in the bucket in comparison to correcting this immense problem that we seem helpless to address through our legal processes.

If anything, the Mexican government should acknowledge the problem as beyond their immediate control and post signage preventing swimming or fishing within a five mile radius of the outflow zone. Who knows how many people and animals have been affected by the contaminated water and seafood? It’s not too late to begin to correct this problem.

-- BEN HUESO




23 Comments so far on this story...

Councilman Hueso. You're a brave man. Not for kayaking in open sea, but for braving the Mexican waters south of San Diego. I have traveled there for years and I too have seen raw sewage beeing dumped right on to beautiful beaches near hotels visited by Americans. I hope you use your authority on the Coastal Commission to bring more attention to the connection between Mexico's sewage and our own beaches' safety. Keep up the good work. We'll be watching.

Posted by Joe6Pack | reply to this comment
September 16, 2007 7:43 pm

Thanks, I just tossed my dinner. That is disgusting! Yuck. Remind me to never go back to TJ.

Posted by Billy Bob Henry | reply to this comment
September 16, 2007 8:47 pm

Thanks Ben for highlighting the problem of the sewage pouring into the ocean south of Playas--and contaminating the coast from Coronado south to Rosarito. We look forward to working wtih you to push for a comprehensive solution to the problem of cross-border ocean contamination. What has been great of late is the active interest on the part of Mexican authorities, the private sector and the residents of northern Baja about this issue. And finally--we need to help clean this up so we make sure that kids from the South Bay don't get sick from having fun in the ocean. Serge Dedina Executive Director WiLDCOAST/COSTASALVA Imperial Beach/Tijuana

Posted by Serge Dedina | reply to this comment
September 17, 2007 7:39 am

What an absolutely spectacular article. It actually made me think I was there. We need to help our neighbors to the south. From the reports, they are trying to get a handle on a sewage system for the Tijuana area. It is a really big undertaking to say the least. Until that is completed, there will continue to be severe problems. The sooner they get their sewer system done, the sooner the outflow will be stopped. We hav to control what we do on our side of the border and need to update our sewer plants to Clean Water standards, but unless we have the cooperation from ther officials in the Tijuana area ( and a sewage treatment plant bought and paid for by them on their side of the border) our Ocean and our environment are at risk, Great article.

Posted by San Marcos says, | reply to this comment
September 17, 2007 7:41 am

I would happily do what I can but need you to suggest a course of action. I can send letters to Mayor Jorge Ramos, and Baja California’s new governor, José Guadalupe Osuna Millin, but who are the San Diego elected officials that will take action to improve the conditions? The information about the Trump Tower Resort being contructed over that gross water is disgusting. Who are the Mexian-American liaisons between our governments? What are their names and phone numbers? Who do they work for? Are they local, state, federal,internationa Are they working together..are there meetings? Do they even know who their counterparts are? How do we help??

Posted by Who do we write? | reply to this comment
September 17, 2007 8:08 am

Wow! The reference to Google Earth sent me off to see for myself -- amazing! And relentless. That outflow will continue for years without pressure to change things. Is there anything comparable to the US-Canada International Joint Commission (see link that helps "prevent and resolve disputes relating to the use and quality of boundary waters"? That model has made huge steps to address quality issues in the Great Lakes, some very similar to your story of raw sewage discharge carried by the currents across international borders.

Posted by Rick Beach | reply to this comment
September 17, 2007 8:28 am

I can only say, "Duh!" I worked on the border sewage in 1984 as part of Duncan Hunter's staff and later on Brian Bilbray's staff when he became a County Supervisor. I wrote the ordinance that told the County Health Department to erectwarning signs in the TJ River Valley and other areas affected by the aguas negras. Since then we've had subsequent Supervisors and San Diego Council members who've abdicated leadership in this issue and the "leaders" have become the obstructionists who block the Bajagua plant because they're upset the developers might actually make a profit and that they gave contributions to politicians. Voice of SD perpetuates the voice of the naysayers with its constant promotion of Serge Dedina of Wildcoast. Councilman Hueso: it's your turn to be a real leader with guts to do the right thing.

Posted by Bob Hudson | reply to this comment
September 17, 2007 8:34 am

Ben: You were paddling through the outfall of the Tijuana regions still developing sewerage system. Tijuana's waste disposal approach is 100 years behind what we do on the north side of the border. Raw sewerage is dumped directly into the Pacific Ocean just off the Rosarito beach area. But of course that doesn't prevent Donald Trump and his developer buddies from going down there and constructing thousands of new condos that will only exacerbate the problem. One problem is that neither the Mexican federal government or local governments are requiring developers to help fix the sewerage mess before making it worse. So anyone dumb enough to buy down there is warned that they're living around a sewer.

Posted by Watcher | reply to this comment
September 17, 2007 10:04 am

Mr. Hueso: I have always loved the Mexican people, the average Mexican citizen, if you will. I am honored and personally enriched to have many Mexican-American friends. Because of that, it is so profoundly difficult for me to ever understand why the ruling elite in Mexico -- from the highest offices of Mexico City down to the local TJ officials -- treat their people so shabbily, even recklessly, with the environmental mess that plagues many parts of that nation. A lot of it, as you reference, then flows through the air or water to our country, which means that we in the San Diego area are also subjected to sewage and pollution. (And let's not overlook the hundreds of millions of 1980s oil money that was stolen by these government and business thieves that could have made a huge, positive difference in hte lives of the Mexican people...)

Posted by Robert E. Lee #1 | reply to this comment
September 17, 2007 10:12 am

Continued... This is my long-winded way of asking you why you think things will really be any different this time around? I had hoped, as a 'neighbor' of Mexico, that when President Fox was elected 6 or 7 years ago, things would change for the better. Call me naive, but I had hoped that Fox, a leader in PAN, who broke the decades-long stranglehold that PRI had on the government, would make a difference. Nope. Wrong. Very wrong. So, again, how do you, in your heart of hearts, think things are going to improve south of the border? Thanks...

Posted by Robert E. Lee #2 | reply to this comment
September 17, 2007 10:23 am

Oh, yeah... What things are YOU personally doing as a member of the Coastal Commission to address this and other San Diego-area coastal issues? Specifics, please...

Posted by Robert E. Lee #3 | reply to this comment
September 17, 2007 10:30 am

Ben. You lament partially treated sewage dumped on the Mexican beach a few miles south. What are you personally doing to stop the 25 million gallons of partially treated sewage being dumped a few miles off imperial beach every day by our own government? What upgrade solution do you support for the borde sewage plant?

Posted by justcleanit! | reply to this comment
September 17, 2007 11:00 am

We really have 2 separate issues here. We have the "partially treated" sewage from our side of the border which needs to be completely treated at our facility - (the money is available for the improvement now, but was not available until recently). We have a good mix of environmentalists, engineers, and experts that can assist with the upgrade. The second issue is Tijuana's RAW sewage that runs down streets, alleys, and runs into the Pacific Ocean. That is another thing entirely. That sewage must first be controlled and pumped to a facility to clean it. And that is where the Mexican government agencies can get nvolved. They have the power to order a facility to be built. The land is available. This is the place for Bajagua. Not tied into United States resources. That is not fair to anyone.

Posted by San Marcos says, | reply to this comment
September 17, 2007 12:37 pm

Councilman Hueso: kudos for taking on this issue. The sewage you experienced is part of an overwhelmed and underfunded system. Fortunately, a solution does exist with the help of the United States, which, as you so aptly noted, is impacted by the sewage flows being dragged by the current along our coast...that solution is Bajagua. The plant will allow for the treatment of 25 mgd of sewage currently being dumped in violation of the Clean Water Act, as well as 34 mgd of sewage estimated by the US EPA to exist in the basin along the Rio Tijuana and Rio Alamar. Bajagua will also help the San Antonio de los Buenos plant operate at stated capacity thus preventing the by-passed discharge you experience while kayaking. We need your voice, along with others to prevent anti-private sector obstructionists from thwarting this important project for US water quality.

Posted by CraigB | reply to this comment
September 17, 2007 2:41 pm

Councilman Hueso: thanks again for bringing this issue to us in an understandable manner. We have all been told that our Pacific Ocean is in trouble, the kelp beds ruined. Please keep an open mind and be aware that there are two different isues that confront us. We have the US treatment plant that MUST be updated and utilized to process our wastewater to Clean Water standards. And we also have the RAW sewage from the Tijuana valley area which first must be contaned and then must be treated. We all know that the government officials of Tijuana are hard at work toward those goals. Try to keep the self-serving Bajagua-ites from clouding the issues. They can build their treating facility and treat the RAW sewage to bring it to acceptable limits. After treatment, the waste can be released !

Posted by San Marcos says, | reply to this comment
September 17, 2007 3:07 pm

Nosotros en COSTASALVAjE estamos empeñados en LIMPIAR LA COSTA YA! –paso a pasito empezando por buscar que se traten los millones de galones de aguas negras solamente tratadas a nivel primario, que se tiran diario a las olas a unas millas de Imperial Beach. El responsable de esa contaminación es el gobierno de California USA., uno de los mas ricos del mundo. Ben puede ayudarnos a empezar ahí, pidiendo que se expanda la planta de San Ysidro. Para seguir, queremos pedir a los desarrolladores estadounidenses como Trump y compañía, que al construir no lo hagan a lo barato, sino bien, invirtiendo en infraestructura para tratar las aguas negras de sus horribles edificios/ torres.

Posted by Fay Crevoshay | reply to this comment
September 17, 2007 3:52 pm

Para seguir, queremos pedir a los desarrolladores estadounidenses como Trump y compañía, que al construir no lo hagan a lo barato, sino bien, invirtiendo en infraestructura para tratar las aguas negras de sus horribles edificios/ torres. Luego conviene que los compradores de los condominios y casas en la costa de Baja California se pongan las pilas y se den cuenta que cuando compran sin preguntar como están construidos los edificios en los que están invirtiendo, les están vendiendo gato por liebre. Esos hermosos condominios con vista al mar, en unos años (no en mucho tiempo sino que el año que entra o el que sigue) van a oler como si estuvieran colocados enfrente de un escusado gigante. De hecho, ya hay días en los que vuele mal por todo Rosarito. CUIDADO! LA CONTAMINACION NOS AFECTA A TODOS SIN EXSEPCION Y MATA A LA VIDA MARITIMA

Posted by FAY Crevoshay | reply to this comment
September 17, 2007 3:54 pm

Great, you re-identified a long term problem. Don't see how we can afford to pay for Mexico's pollution issues, when we don't fully take care of own environmental issues. We all know that Mexico wants Uncle Sugar to solve this one for them, too. By the way Mr. Hueso, why did you believe that The Lodge, at Torrey Pines, deserved $100.00+ cabanas at Torrey Pines State Beach? What don't you understand about the concept of a PUBLIC PARK? Is selling out public access, of public lands, part of your funding solution(s); or, do you just like performing favors for a major San Diego Hotel interest?

Posted by Torrey Pines | reply to this comment
September 17, 2007 4:06 pm

Well, blow me down, Hueso; so this is what it takes to get some California land lubbers to wake up and smell the breeze from the sea, eh? They sure weren't listening years ago when my dad, a tuna clipper captain, went to Congress to tell them much the same story. Too much developer money drowned out that message. Though Un-PC, it's time the USA really did "export democracy" to a country that could use it; like Mexico. We could and should infiltrate their beaches and erect taxpayer-supported sewage treatment centers. We should do this because the slime you kayaked through is a public health disaster waiting to happen, and when it does, many on both sides of the line will die. Warmer water and thicker sludge will tip the balance against coastal California; we'd better get on this one ASAP, even if we have go it alone.

Posted by The Old Man & the Sea | reply to this comment
September 17, 2007 5:06 pm

Oh and another thing; leave those Baja crabs and lobsters alone. They're bottom feeders you know, and you probably don't want to know what they've been feeding on for the last couple of generations, eh? Try vegetarianism immediately.

Posted by H. Salt | reply to this comment
September 17, 2007 5:15 pm

this has been happening for a long time, I am surprised that as an avid kayaker he has never seen this before. people have been working on this tirelessly. also, if anyone would take the time to work with the mexican officials on this they would see that it is also a problem for them and they would work to help solve it. let's see more action and less talk.

Posted by old news | reply to this comment
September 18, 2007 9:33 am

Swimming in polluted waters should be nothing new to a member of our lackluster City Council.

Posted by Black Sabbath | reply to this comment
September 18, 2007 4:05 pm

Mr.Hueso; Please let us know what your research is to substaniate your allegation that the Trump Baja Resort will discharge their raw sewage into the ocean.

Posted by La Verdad | reply to this comment
October 3, 2007 12:03 pm


Reader feedback
  • Users may post more than one comment, but should not pose as multiple users. Multiple posts from the same IP address but with a different user name on each will be reviewed to determine whether abuse has occurred.
  • Posts with overly personal attacks or unsubstantiated allegations may be edited or deleted.
  • Please be patient with the posts -- there may be a delay before they appear on the site -- and make sure to enter the code in the "image verification" box.
Post a comment
Name:
Email:
Comments:
Current Word Count: Verification Code
959b96d

Sign Up for Daily and Breaking News Alerts

Don't want to miss a story? Want to be the first to know about breaking news? Sign up now.

This Just In

WSJ: Lerach to Plead Guilty:

 The San Diego securities attorney faces a prison term of one to two years, according to the Wall Street Journal. » Sep. 17 -- 5:35 pm



One Guy's Stadium Proposal:

 A local financial analyst presents an unsolicited idea for a stadium/arena/convention center megaplex in Mission Valley.

Sep. 17 -- 5:30 pm


DeMaio Sells Business:

 The candidate for the District 5 council seat will remain an advisory chairman at the Performance Institute.

Sep. 17 -- 11:24 am


MOST POPULAR STORIES:

SURVIVAL IN SAN DIEGO

Attrition in Real Estate :

  The industry bleeds agents and brokers and mortgage people and escrow officers and construction workers.

Sep. 17 -- 6:19 pm



LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

Politicians Are the Problem:

 

Sep. 16 -- 6:06 pm



CAFÉ SAN DIEGO

Dealing With the Coastal Mess:

 There have been no serious efforts on the Mexican government to address cross-border sewage, and our own government in D.C. has mishandled the issue.

Sep. 17 -- 5:05 pm



COMMENTARY: SLOP

A Fall Vacation :

  I'm headed for a nice break.

Sep. 16 -- 5:50 pm



COMMENTARY: RICH TOSCANO

Must-Sell Housing Supply Overwhelms Demand :

  Home sales are dwindling as mortgage defaults pile up like never before.

Sep. 17 -- 1:30 pm


Copyright © 2008 voiceofsandiego.org. All Rights Reserved.